Thinking about Privacy in Healthcare data, it is important to understand the context in which privacy is being sought, who is seeking privacy, from whom, and in what situations.
Lets understand the context of the demand/ need for privacy of health data.
There are social, as well as work/ business reasons why patients are concerned about who gets access to their health data. Social reasons vary from the differentiation in day-to-day lives that some of the people start experiencing once their medical condition is known in their social circle. Examples range from well publicized cases of sports persons to legislators to celebrities, who become the focus of sympathy/ avoidance/ branding etc., whether consciously done or sub-consciously done. This phenomenon has been well documented in the past 20 years of multiple exposures incidents. It is important to note that in the absence of these disclosures, the lives of these individuals were going just fine, when an unauthorized disclosure turned things upside down.
The second main concern against disclosures is to prevent employment discrimination. Employers are increasingly incurring higher costs of health insurance and more employers are moving towards the self-insured model. This means that they are directly impacted by the health condition of each of their employees, and there is a natural interest in managing their employee population and their health conditions. While most employers focus on better management of health conditions, there is a potential that some may engage in screening their employee population and making hiring, jobs allocations, retention and retrenchments based on knowledge about specific health conditions of employees. While overtly, such decisions may be justified on other grounds, the underlying driver could very well be health conditions.
Needless to say, discrimination based on health condition at a social and professional level significantly impacts the patients adversely and is the prime driver of the concern about keeping a close tab on who has access to medical information and in what situations.
Creating a water tight ecosystem to control health information access and to track disclosures has its complexities and nuances. More about it as we go along.